Mergers are often justified by cost savings and greater efficiency. But does this also hold in industries where traditional competition is absent and prices are controlled by regulators? Could a merger between two companies paradoxically lead to higher costs for consumers?

These are the questions explored by Richard Kališ from the Faculty of Economics and Finance at the Bratislava University of Economics and Business and Peter Bogetoft from Copenhagen Business School in their study Merger Remedies in Frontier-Based Regulation, published in the prestigious European Journal of Operational Research. Using data from Danish electricity distribution companies, they show why cost savings from mergers do not necessarily translate into savings for consumers and how regulators can mitigate these effects.

We spoke with Richard not only about the findings of the study, but also about how a chance encounter at a conference in Portugal led to an international collaboration, a research stay in Copenhagen, and eventually a joint publication.


Let's start with the basics. What exactly did you study, and why should we care?

We were interested in what happens when two companies merge in an industry where traditional competition does not exist. Typical examples include electricity or water distribution companies. If you live at a particular address, you cannot choose which company's electricity network delivers electricity to your home. That is why these companies are generally subject to price regulation.

However, the regulator still needs to determine what costs, and consequently what prices, are reasonable in the absence of competition. One way to do this is by comparing companies with one another. If some companies can provide comparable services at lower costs, others should be encouraged to achieve similar levels of efficiency. In this way, the regulator effectively substitutes for the competition that would otherwise be missing from the market.

So what is the problem when two such companies merge? Given that they operate as natural monopolies, shouldn't a merger generate savings?

Exactly, and that is where the interesting paradox comes in. A merger between two companies can indeed generate savings. For example, they may no longer need two headquarters, or they may be able to make better use of their employees or shared infrastructure.

However, there is also a second effect that is often overlooked in regulated industries. When two companies merge, the regulator loses one independent company against which the others can be compared. And if that company was among the most efficient, the remaining companies may suddenly face less demanding cost-efficiency requirements.

The result may therefore be that the two merging companies achieve savings, but the regulator allows higher costs for other companies. Ultimately, these additional costs may be passed on to consumers through higher prices.

How did you investigate these effects?

We used data on 51 electricity distribution companies in Denmark. We simulated all 1,275 possible pairwise mergers and examined how each would affect costs across the entire industry.

At the same time, we compared three different approaches that a regulator could adopt in response to a merger. These ranged from a straightforward approach, in which the merged company is treated similarly to other companies, to more stringent rules designed to maintain pressure on firms to reduce costs.

Our aim was therefore not simply to estimate how much the two merging companies could save, but, more importantly, to understand what would happen to all the other companies as a consequence.

And what were your main findings? What should regulators take away from your research?

Our findings suggest that, in most of the scenarios we examined, the negative indirect effects of a merger outweigh the savings generated by the merger itself. From the consumers' perspective, it may therefore be preferable for the companies not to merge at all.

However, much depends on which companies are merging. The greatest problems arise when one of them is among the most efficient and serves as a benchmark for many others. Removing such a company from the comparison can weaken the pressure to reduce costs across a substantial part of the industry.

At the same time, we show that appropriately designed regulatory rules can mitigate these negative effects. This does not mean that regulators should automatically prevent mergers. Rather, they should consider not only the potential savings of the merging companies but also the broader consequences for the entire industry and its customers.

How did your collaboration with Peter Bogetoft from Copenhagen Business School come about?

It all started more or less by chance. At a conference in Porto, Portugal, I was presenting the results of my doctoral research, which had already been published as a scientific article. It was there that I met Peter, who is one of the pioneers of the methodology I had been using in my research.

After the conference, he approached me and asked whether we might try working on something together. I suggested that I could come to Copenhagen for that purpose. I managed to secure a scholarship through the National Scholarship Programme administered by SAIA, and from January to May 2023, I undertook a research stay at Copenhagen Business School. I later returned in October and November, this time as a part-time researcher employed directly by the University of Copenhagen.

During the first part of my stay, in January 2023, we began working on the research that eventually became our joint article.

What did you take away from your stay in Copenhagen? Was there anything about the academic environment that particularly surprised you?

What fascinated me most was how much people there live and breathe research. Their Department of Economics is roughly comparable in size to our entire faculty, yet researchers are not further divided into traditional departments or academic units. Instead, they form flexible research groups based on their research interests.

There was some kind of seminar practically every day. These ranged from large research seminars featuring invited international scholars, similar to those we organise at NHF, to public lectures. During my stay, for example, Nobel laureate in economics Eric Maskin gave a lecture there.

To be fair, what interested me even more were the so-called brown bag seminars, where PhD students presented research at a very early stage. Sometimes they had little more than an idea or a research question they wanted to explore. Individual research groups also organised their own smaller seminars on specialised topics, such as finance or microeconomics.

What I particularly appreciated was that discussing research was not something exceptional there, but a natural part of everyday academic life. People did not wait until they had a finished paper. Quite the opposite: they discussed their ideas while they were still taking shape.

You mentioned that you first came to Copenhagen in 2023, yet the article was not published until 2026. Is it common for the publication process to take so long?

Yes, especially in high-quality international journals, the publication process can be quite lengthy. We started working on the paper in January 2023, submitted it to the journal in autumn 2024, and it was finally accepted in February 2026. In the meantime, it went through several rounds of peer review, comments, and revisions.

European Journal of Operational Research is one of the leading international academic journals in its field. Publishing there is not easy, as manuscripts undergo rigorous peer review. Some reviewers' comments can mean weeks or even months of additional work.

In our case, for example, one of the three reviewers began their report with the words: "I want to see a paper on this topic in this journal, but not this particular paper."

That sounded rather harsh, almost cynical. However, the reviewer then went on to provide several pages of detailed comments, which we gradually addressed. Ultimately, those comments helped us take the paper to an entirely different level.